Ask Mr. Science
page 19

 
arrow left arrow up arrow right
prev page
 
index
 
next page
 

 

The birds in the truck

I got the following story:

"I'm following behind this truck. Every time the truck comes to a bridge, the driver stops, gets out, bangs on the side of the truck, gets back in and crosses the bridge. This happens a few times, so when the truck pulls into a gas station I decide follow it in and ask the driver why he does this. He explains that he is close to the load limit of the bridges, and that he's carrying birds. When he bangs on the truck, he thinks the birds fly up and his truck gets lighter - then he crosses the bridge."

Is the driver right or not?

OK,....

29 January 2004

 

Why does a fly inside a car not splat against the windshield?

This is about inertia:. If an object is at rest it wants to stay at rest, and when it is moving it wants to keep moving (see the link to Isaac Newton, below). If you have a golfball on the floor of the car, and you start driving, the ball rolls towards back of the car - the car's motor starts the car going forward, but the golf ball wants to say at rest - it wants to stay where it is, while the car moves out from under it. Conversely, if the car is going, and you stap on the brake, the ball will roll forward in the car: maybe the car wants to slow down, but the golf ball want to keep going.

Suppose I'm in a car, holding a contraption like shown on the right: it is a coathanger, bent into an (inverted) L-shape, and with a golfball taped to one end as shown. When the car starts up, the golfball wants to stay behind, and will swing backwards. If I grip the coathanger tightly, I can try to prevent this.

In the classroom, I can take a quick step forward, and the ball will swing towards my chest. Same thing, but now with a pingpong ball taped on. Again, if I take a quick step forward, the pingpong ball will swing towards my chest. If I want to prevent this by gripping the vertical part of the coathanger, it will be easier than trying to do this with the golfball. Now I connect the two. What will happen when I step forward now? Since the golfball is much heavier than th epinpong ball, the golfball 'wins': the golfball will go towards my chest, and the pingpong ball will be forced forwards.
(More to come...)

 

How much does the Earth weigh?

This is about estimating the weight of something really big, if you can handle only a small sample of it.
(Apologies to the purists for freely mixing up mass and weight in what follows).

I started with an example a little closer to home: in the ceiling of the school's lobby there are these giant exposed wood beams. (I actually handled every one of them myself). How would you figure out the weight of these beams? I introduced the idea of density, the weight per unit volume of a material. I still had a block of wood that had been cut off one of the beams, and we measured it (6cm × 25cm × 25cm), and weighed it on my kitchen scale (1650 g) . The density then is:

               weight     1650 g
density = -------- = ---------   = 0.44 g/cm3
volume     3750 cm3
Then we calculated the volume of the beams, which were 12"×12"×22' or 30cm × 30cm × 700cm = 630000 cm3.

Each one of these cm3 weighs 0.44 grams, so the whole beam weighs 630000 × 0.44 = 277000 grams, or 277 kilos, or 600 lbs. (In 1997, the wood was much greener, and the beams weighed more than 800 lbs each).

You can see we did lots of unit conversions, which takes some patience in 6th grade. To give them a feeling of what grams an kilograms are in real life, I had brought my standard 1-gram weight (a dollar bill), and 1-liter bottle of water (=1 kilogram).

Now we did the same for the earth. The core of the earth consists of iron, and the outer crust is of course mostly rock. In between is the mantle, composed of molten rock. Using the same procedure as with the wood block, we measured the density of a slab of iron I had brought in, and of rock (a chunk of local sandstone). The density of iron came in at 5.7 g/cm3, and the density of the stone was about 2.7 g/cm3. So the average density of the Earth is somewhere between 2.7 and 5.7. Since the crust only makes up a small portion, and there is compression of material as you go deeper and deeper down, it turns out that for the whole Earth the average density is about 5.5 g/cm3: our tabletop measurements were in the right ballpark.

Next, we needed to find out the volume of the Earth. Luckily, the kids in this class knew the story of Eratosthenes of Alexandria. I was impressed! Eratosthenes had figured out the circumference of the Earth (see the links below), and got the answer correct at about 40000 km. That means the diameter is 12000 km. What is the volume of a sphere if you know the diameter? I used the approximation that it is about half of the volume of a cube that just fits around the sphere.

We were starting to deal with too many zeros, so I showed how to write the number of zeros in scientific notation. So the diameter of the Earth was now written as 12×103 km, or
12×106 m, or
12×108 cm.
The volume of a cube that size is 12×12×12×1024 cm3, and the volume of the Earth is half that, or 850×1024 cm3.

Weight is volume times density, so

Weight of the Earth = 850×5.5×1024 grams, or
4675×1024 g, or
4.7×1024 kg, or
10×1024 lbs

As a final touch, does a number with 24 zeros have a name? Starting with our knowledge of millions and billions, we made the following table:

numberlatin
word
namenumber of zeros
1mono.. million 6
2 bi.. billion 9
3 tri.. trillion 12
4 quatr.. quadrillion 15
5 quint.. quintillion 18
6 sext.. sextillion 21
7 sept.. septillion 24
8 oct.. octillion 27

Therefore the approximate weight of the Earth is ten septillion pounds.







Suggestions, comments, greetings are greatly appreciated.
Just click here
and type away!

arrow left arrow up arrow right
prev page index next page
Back to my home page